The PBS documentary “Stripped for Parts: American Journalism on the Brink” is more than a story about struggling newspapers. It is a warning about what happens when financial interests dismantle institutions that help hold communities — and democracies — together.
The film argues that local newspapers were not simply weakened by technology and changing consumer habits but systematically hollowed out by investment firms focused on extracting profits rather than sustaining journalism.
For years, Americans assumed newspapers were disappearing because of the internet. “Stripped for Parts” highlights a more uncomfortable truth: Many newspapers did not merely decline — they were deliberately stripped down. Among the most prominent examples is Alden Global Capital, one of the nation’s largest newspaper owners. In city after city, newsrooms were reduced, investigative reporting was cut, buildings were sold and veteran journalists were laid off.
The hedge fund model is straightforward. Newspapers continue generating subscription revenue, advertising income, legal notice revenue and digital traffic. By cutting expenses faster than revenues decline, investors can continue extracting profits even as journalism deteriorates.
Additional gains often come from selling valuable newspaper properties, printing facilities and other long-held assets. The result is a double harvest: Profits are maintained through cost-cutting while decades of accumulated real estate value are converted into immediate financial returns.
To investors, a newsroom may appear to be a cost center. To communities it may be one of the last institutions connecting citizens to local government, shared facts and civic accountability.
To understand what is being lost, it is worth recalling the historic role newspapers played in American civic life. From the founding of the Republic, newspapers played a central role in American civic life. They informed citizens, fostered debate and connected communities.
Local newspapers became the public square of towns and cities, covering school boards, city councils, elections, business developments and neighborhood concerns.
Most importantly, newspapers created a shared set of facts. Citizens could disagree politically while still understanding the same local reality. That common foundation helped sustain civil discourse and democratic accountability.
Today thousands of newspapers have disappeared or become shadows of their former selves, creating what researchers call “news deserts.” School board meetings receive little scrutiny. Local corruption often goes uncovered. Civic participation declines. Citizens frequently know more about political battles in Washington than decisions affecting their own communities.
The vacuum rarely remains empty. Social media algorithms replace local editors. National outrage replaces local engagement. Rumors and misinformation spread more easily when fewer professional journalists are available to verify facts and provide context.
Ironically, Americans now have access to more information than at any point in history, yet many communities are less informed about themselves. Unlimited information does not automatically produce understanding.
Democracies depend not only on constitutions and elections but also on institutions that connect citizens to one another and sustain a shared civic reality. Local journalism has historically served that role. When such institutions disappear, societies become more vulnerable to manipulation, fragmentation, misinformation and disinformation.
The collapse of local journalism is not simply a media issue; it is a national resilience issue. Communities without trusted local reporting become easier to divide politically and socially. Foreign adversaries increasingly exploit polarization and distrust through information warfare. Fragmented societies become strategically weaker.
This is why “Stripped for Parts” raises a larger question: Should local journalism be treated purely as a commodity, or as part of the civic infrastructure necessary for democracy to function?
America long ago recognized that some institutions are too important to be judged solely by profitability. Public schools educate future citizens. Courts uphold the rule of law. Libraries preserve knowledge. Fire departments protect lives and property. Society supports these institutions because their value extends far beyond financial return.
Local journalism may deserve similar consideration. If an informed citizenry is essential to self-government, communities may need to view local news as civic infrastructure worthy of philanthropic support, nonprofit models, public-private partnerships or other sustainable funding mechanisms that preserve both independence and accountability.
“Stripped for Parts” reminds us that societies often fail to recognize the value of civic institutions until they begin to disappear. The erosion happens quietly — one newsroom, one reporter, one newspaper at a time — until communities realize that nobody is left watching city hall, asking difficult questions, or telling the story of the place they call home.
When communities lose their newspapers, they often lose far more than news. They lose part of the civic fabric that informs citizens, holds leaders accountable and helps sustain democracy itself.
John Barry, of Aurora, is a retired U.S. Air Force major general, former superintendent of Aurora Public Schools and CEO of the Wings Over the Rockies Museum.
The Colorado Sun is a nonpartisan news organization, and the opinions of columnists and editorial writers do not reflect the opinions of the newsroom. Read our ethics policy for more on The Sun’s opinion policy. Learn how to submit a column. Reach the opinion editor at opinion@coloradosun.com.
Follow Colorado Sun Opinion on Facebook.